Top 5 Best Rated Push Reel Mower of 2018 [Review & Buyer’s Guide]


Having a well-kept lawn is one of the things that will help make your home look beautiful, attractive and pleasant to the eyes. It is therefore important that you take care of the lawn in a proper way that will not only make your lawn attractive but that it will also make your lawn one that your visitors will long to relax in or even party on.

Best Pull Reel Mower

One of the things that will make your lawn look tidy, decent and attractive to your visitors is the kind of mower that you make use of. As a result of this, it is necessary for you to know how best to go about getting the lawn mower. It is equally very important and necessary for you to know some of the leading brand names of mowers as this will help guide you in choosing which the best for you.

Let’s take a look at some of the best push mowers on the market:

American Lawn Mower 1204-14 hand reel 14-inc push lawn mower

This sturdy, classic-design model is manufactured by the American Lawn Mower Company, a company founded in 1895 with the sole purpose of designing and producing the most efficient push mower possible. This model is especially useful for cutting the “cooler season” grasses like fescue, bluegrass, and rye. It delivers a clean, razor-likeprecision cut for most types of turf grasses. In fact, to ensure that their product delivers a perfect cut, each push mower produced by the American Lawn Mower Company is tested by cutting a piece of paper that measures 1/3000 of an inch in thickness, a great deal thinner than even the most delicate blade of grass.

Even when dealing with unusually tall grass, this push mower can speed through the job where a motorized mower might be bogged down and require re-starling and possible the added work of trimming the grass before mowing, depending on the capabilities of the power mower.

The Push Mower features an adjustable cutting height of .5″ to 1.5″ and a 14–inch cutting width. Other premium features include:

  • High -impact, 8.5″ polymer wheels which feature integral, molded tread for endurance and smooth performance
  • A triple-sectioned, adjustable roller; a three-spider, single-blade reel, a bed knife blade, and an alloy steel
  • Plastic grips cover the sturdy, zinc-plated mower handles for comfort and no-slip safety grip.
  • Lightweight, 19-pound design.

The American 1204-14 offers its users every essential property that is needed to achieve a perfectly manicured lawn. It is lightweight, easy to use, adjustable and durable. With its steel alloy reels being adjustable, this lawn mower allows you to trim grass from a length of an inch to 1 an inch. This is a property that is present in only top-notch lawn mowers, and since it is not an electric lawn mower, these properties will ensure its optimal performance.

American Lawn Mower 1415-16 16-inc push lawn mower

This push mower, also manufactured by same company as above, is built to last and delivers a performance that makes doing the yard work a pleasure rather than a chore well, almost! By utilizing manpower rather than gasoline or electricity, this mower eliminates both air pollution and noise, a rare feat in a world where modern machinery, no matter how harmful to the atmosphere, overrides such considerations in the name of convenience. This mower solid design and durability guarantee years of reliable performance.

The American Lawn Mower 1415-16 features several details that make the perfect tool for lawn care, including:

  • Settings to accommodate lawns up to 4″ in height (cutting adjustments from .5″ to 2.5″)
  • 3-position adjustable wheel height and an adjustable roller with four sections.
  • Radial-grade tread tires on durable, 10″ cast iron, composite wheels.
  • Generous 16″ cutting width
  • Sturdy yet lightweight 25-pound design for easy handling and precision mowing.
  • Quadruple spider five blades and ball bearing reel.
  • Tempered alloy steel blades and reel were secured in position by an unbreakable steel plate.

Unlike the electric lawn mowers that operate on an engine and motor, the American 1415-16 is operated by manually pushing it over the lawn that you need to trim. It is self-propelled, featuring a reel or roller that rotates along with the wheels whenever the lawn mower is pushed over the lawn. In this case, the reel features a 4-section roller that holds every blade of grass and pushes it against the bed knife blade. The sharp knife blade will then cut the grass to the desired length between and 2% inches. With its self-propelled design, this push reel mower requires no batteries or recharging, thus reliable and convenient as it can be used at any time. It surely is the ultimate worthy investment for a clean and attractive lawn.

Great states 204-14 hand reel 14-inc push lawn mower

Many people prefer the simplicity of a classic design combined with the performance of a much more elaborate and costly piece of equipment. That is exactly what the Great States 201-14 delivers. Clean lines, no-frills, sturdy construction, and top-performing features at a great price make this model one of the top Great States favorites. This model is among the most preferred for work on sloping areas and uneven ground as its lightweight construction and handling make lawn care a breeze even in more challenging areas.

The Great States Hand Reel Push Mower boasts an impressive list of user-preferred features such as

  • Adjustable 3-sectioned roller for cutting heights from .5″ to 1.5″
  • Alloy steel bed knife blade and reel.
  • Durable, high-impact 8.5″ polymer wheels featuring molded integral tread.
  • Formed tension tube with steel side plates.
  • Lightweight but sturdy 20-pound design.
  • Convenient folding handles for easy storage.
  • Generous 14″ cutting width for quicker work.
  • Precision cuts on wet or dry grass.

The Great States 204-14 is an amazing choice for anyone seeking a really affordable lawn mower. As much as it will take quite some effort to cut grass with it as compared to electric lawn mowers, it is more effective and less noisy. Its reel and blade have been designed to work perfectly together, achieving a clean trim for your lawn. With most of its users praising it by its excellence in trimming grass, it surely is the machine to give a try. Its excellence can be attributed to its ease of maneuverability, transportation, and storage, its ease of use, as well as its highly effective features.

Great states 815-18 five blade 18-inc push lawn mower

The Great States 815-18 holds a place among the elite of push mowers. One look of this state-of-the-art design tells you that this is no ordinary reel mower. Taking into account that most lawns are not the size of a postage stamp and therefore require a bit more blade space to get the job done promptly, this little gem provides just that. The 18″ blade on this push mower features a cutting area that is nearly 50% bigger than most other push mowers, with five razor-sharp blades instead of one. The streamlined design and extra-durable construction guarantee that this mower will deliver A-1 results for many years to come.

The Great States 815-18 assures premium results with this list of features:

  • Adjustable cutting height from .5″ to 2.75.”
  • Sturdy 10″ ball-hearing wheels.
  • Powder-coated loop-style handle grip finish for comfort, safety, and protection against rust.
  • Impressive 1.5-foot cutting blade width.
  • Five premium quality, heat-treated alloy steel blades for longer-lasting sharpness and extended performance.
  • Easy to handle yet sturdy 28-pound weight.
  • Radial tread tires for durability.
  • Ultra-easy, 4-bolt assembly.

The Great States 815-18 is the ultimate choice for anyone looking for durability, strength, and power. As much as it is a push mower, its features are designed to ensure maximum results. Its heat-treated blades are among its most incredible features. They are designed to stay sharp for longer and to trim grass clean, giving you a well-groomed lawn. By investing in this lawn mower, you will be satisfied with the fact that you skip the fumes, noise, oil, cords, recharging, and gas. The excellent results achieved by the Great States 815-18 cannot be ignored as they are truly incredible.

Great states model 304-14 five blade 14-inc push lawn mower

The Great States 304-14 features a classic, simple-to-operate design for fast yard work with beautiful results. In keeping with the traditional idea of manicuring a lawn with little fuss and minimal effort, this model is lightweight and precise. It delivers a razor-sharp cut so that lawns are left uniform and healthy as well as pleasing to the eye, with no backtracking or do-overs necessary. Uneven or sloping terrains are no problem for this push mower. It is lightweight enough for easy maneuverability and sturdy enough to remain in place so as to get the job done.

The Model 304-14 push mower boasts some impressive features, including:

  • Zinc-plated, corrosion-resistant handles with plastic grips for safety.
  • 10-inch composite wheels.
  • 14″ cutting width.
  • Adjustable cutting height from 1″ to 1.75.”
  • Five blades, three spider ball bearing reel constructed from alloy steel for scissor-like precision cutting.
  • Radial rubber tires provide increased traction on all terrains.
  • Hard enamel finish looks attractive and protects against corrosion and rust.
  • Simple, fast assembly that requires no tools.

Defined by its manufacturer as one that can be fueled at the price of a banana and a glass of milk, the Great States 304-14 lawn mower model is among the most cost-effective machines of all time. Since it uses no fuel or gas, it does not produce any fumes, unpleasant odors or noise. Since it is cordless, it does not limit its lawn mowing radius and can be used anywhere at any time.
Buying the right push mower
Once you’ve decided to purchase a push mower, there are several factors you will want to take into consideration to make sure you choose the one that is just right for you:

What type of lawn care work will the push mower be used for?

The primary consideration when preparing to buy a push lawn mower is the type and size of the yard(s) it will be used to mow. You will want to keep in mind that any reel -type push lawn mower operates solely on manpower. As long as you are willing to do the physical labor, and if you like the idea of using equipment that doesn’t utilize gasoline or oil and therefore doesn’t create exhaust (read: pollution), then a push mower is perfect for you.
Reel push lawn mowers are available in a wide variety of cutting widths. This will determine the swath of each path you can mow. The greater the cutting width, the wider the swath and the less time the task will take. This is usually a primary buying point, however, of you will be using the push mower on a smaller size yard, or one that contains obstacles such as trees, flower beds, and other stationary objects, you may want to consider buying a push mower with a smaller cutting width for easier maneuverability and precision when cutting around these objects. Of course, there is always the option of combining the use of the push mower with a weed eater or other trimming instrument, but this creates additional work.

Reel-type push lawn mowers can also be used on larger lawns with no problem, as long as the user is prepared to put in the physical work necessary to get the job done. Many people prefer the use of a push mower because they are quiet, unlike Gas Riding Mowers. This is especially a concern where neighbors are close by and if you are an early bird who prefers to get yard work done very early in the day. A push mower is a perfect choice to avoid disturbing the neighborhood with early-morning noise.

How much money do you want to invest in a reel-type push mower?

Push mowers can be found in nearly every price range, depending on their features and quality of workmanship. If you are using your push mower on a small area without challenging terrain or obstacles, then a basic model will likely suit your needs. If your yard is larger, thicker, with various types of grasses, slopes, hills, etc, then you will want to invest in a good, solid push mower that comes equipped with more than one cutting blade, durable tires, and a variety of cutting height settings to accommodate the different areas or types of grass being manicured.

If storage space is a concern, look for a model that has folding handles for compact, easy storage that will require a minimum amount of space. Take the time to make certain that the model you choose requires very little upkeep, such as oiling of the wheels/ball bearings and cleaning and sharpening of the cutting blade(s). A good quality push mower will be able to be stored away and then taken out the following season and used without a great deal of maintenance.
Who will be using the push mower?
Push mowers are among the easiest types of lawn mowers to use, providing that one is willing and able to invest the sweat and energy into using them. When shopping for your push mower, keep in mind who will be mowing the lawn, at least for the majority of the time. Most push mowers are lightweight and manageable enough for even young teens to be able to use them, so size and weight of the equipment is not usually a concern. Height can be, so you may want to check the overall height of handles and look for a model that allows for adjustment. A good push mower will be easy to navigate for most anyone.
How do you want the grass cut?
This means the height at which you will want to maintain your lawn, and also what you want to be done with the clippings themselves. Cutting a lawn too short can cause damage to the grass, resulting in brown patches on your lawn when the hot sun and dry weather burn up your once-healthy grass. This occurs when it is cut too close to the ground and becomes unable to get the necessary moisture and nutrients. You will want to choose a push reel mower with an adjustable cutting feature so that you can choose a setting that will cut your grass to a uniform and healthy height.

Depending on factors such as soil type, climate, precipitation, etc., where you live, the best height to keep your lawn trimmed to can vary greatly, but experts recommend that no lawn be trimmed to a length of less than 1″ in height. The other consideration is the size of the clippings the push reel mower will produce. If you choose a model that provides a longer cut, the grass can be raked up from the lawn after mowing and discarded. If you choose a model that creates shorter clippings, these can be left on the ground to provide a healthy mulch for your lawn. Due to the design of these mowers, they do not usually come with an attachment available to collect the grass clippings, as some motorized mowers do. However, choosing one that creates short, choppy clipping is a great idea for eliminating extra work by having to clean up longer leavings and for doing something good for your lawn by using the shorter clippings to nourish it.

Watch for metal-on-metal contact on the model you chose
Do you want a nice quiet lawn mowing experience, with the minimum amount of noise? Look for a push reel mower with zero metal-on-metal contact. That clicking sound that can be heard when some push mowers are in use is caused by the blades coming into contact with the cutter bar to some extent or other (the more contact, the louder the sound). A well-designed and built push reel mower will have no contact between the two, even if the blades miss the cutting bar by only a few millimeters, This makes for a totally silent cut. It is ultimately better for the mower itself as over time the contact between the two components can result in damage, dulling of the blades, etc. This will affect performance and will eventually require the replacement of the mower.

Be aware, however that there are some mowers whose design has the blade making a small, harmless bit of contact with the cutter bar. This will result in a quiet ‘clicking’ sound as the mower reel rotates while cutting the lawn. This type of contact is not harmful to the mower, and the sound is not loud enough to be annoying in the least. Make certain the blades are aligned properly to avoid any issues which could damage the mower. Research models you may be considering purchasing to make sure this is not an issue. Ask a salesperson to recommend a model that will meet your specifications in this area. While there are those who prefer a push reel mower with the light sound so that they know it is working properly, most opt for a silent experience with lawn cutting.
What type of terrain will you be mowing?
Depending predominantly on what part of the country you live in, the ground can be rough and uneven or smooth and flat as glass. This can present a problem if you are dealing with the former type and you choose a substandard reel push mower model. Take note of the type of ground you are working with when you are looking for a good reel mower. For lawns that are on flat land with little or no rough, hilly areas, a small, lightweight mower will work great. However, if you are in an area where the land is less than even and is going to give any mower a run for the money, then you will need to invest in more sturdy model that features wheels with good tires and a strong, reinforced steel side plates and tempered cutting blades.
Will the reel push mower be the only piece of equipment you use for your lawn work?
Some people choose to have a small arsenal of lawn care equipment, and a push reel mower is only one of the tools they use. Often there is a motorized lawn mower which is used for cutting when the lawn becomes full and requires a more thorough cutting, a weed eater for edge work and trimming, and a reel push mower to keep the lawn neat and manicured in between full mowing. If this is how you will be caring for your lawn, then a primary reel mower will do the trick. A simple, single-blade reel push mower will be able to keep the central part of your yard looking great with just a quick touch-up occasionally. Choose an easy to use, easy to store model that will require only minimal maintenance such as blade sharpening and your lawn care regimen will be a natural process with perfect results every time.

Reel-type push lawn mowers are an asset to the atmosphere in that they don’t emit pollutants into the air like motorized models do. They are safer for use due to their overall design and performance. They are an excellent source of exercise for those who choose them over conventional lawn mowers. It’s refreshing to see that a product with a simple, uncomplicated design is still so effective and sought-after today. With just a bit of research choosing, the right one for your needs is easy, and your lawn will look fantastic all the time!

Related Reviews


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here